Speaking of the Planning Commission approved Transit Center District Plan necessary for the Transbay Transit Tower and Terminal to rise, yesterday Sue Hestor filed an appeal of Planning’s approval on behalf of the Save Our Parks Sunlight Coalition, membership of which is comprised of Ms. Hestor’s organization, San Franciscans for Reasonable Growth.
The appeal alleges the Transit Center District Plan’s Environmental Impact Report (EIR): “Understates the shadow impacts on parks under the protection of Proposition K, a voter-approved ordinance that precludes new shadows on parks under the jurisdiction of the Recreation & Parks Commission” and “[m]isapplies Proposition K by assuming that the Planning Commission and Recreation & Parks Commission can increase the amount of shadow allowed on downtown parks.”
In the opinion of Reuben & Junius:
Though the appeal is completely without merit, CEQA nonetheless mandates the Board of Supervisors consider it-an exercise that will needlessly consume the time and attention of elected officials and waste public funds. To add insult to injury, none of these costs will be paid by the appellant. San Franciscans for Reasonable Growth, which to most regular observers seems to be an organization consisting of one person, apparently received a fee waiver as a “community organization.”
The appeal will likely be heard by San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors next month.
∙ Planning’s Towering Transit Center District Plan Decision: Approved [SocketSite]
∙ Transbay Tower Timeline Moved Up, Payment To City Stays Down [SocketSite]
∙ Shining Light On The Shadows Of The Proposed Transit District Towers [SocketSite]
∙ Two Steps Forward, One Step Back: Transit Center EIR Appealed [reubenlaw.com]