February 26, 2010
Eight Hundred Per Square Foot For Nine Hundred Clayton
While we typically cringe when “period details” are painted over, in this case we like the overall effect (not to mention curb appeal). Asking $2,395,000 when listed in September 2008, they’re asking $2,239,000 ($800 per square) for 900 Clayton today.
∙ Listing: 900 Clayton (4/3) - $2,239,000 [MLS]
First Published: February 26, 2010 11:00 AM
Comments from "Plugged In" Readers
Its so wrong. Nothing makes me sadder. Painting over the beautiful hardwood and period details. It should be banned.
Shame on the decorators.
Posted by: Ronald at February 26, 2010 1:22 PM
The house is beautiful.
Posted by: midcentfan at February 26, 2010 1:42 PM
Not all wood, hardwood or softwood, was meant to be stained..it can come off very dark and dreary.
Painting wood is still considered protecting the surface. In this house, the painted wood is very nice.
Posted by: noearch at February 26, 2010 2:14 PM
A lot of unpainted wood in older homeslooks horrible. It only looks good if you have some sort of fancy wood and a beautiful stain, and even then as noearch said, too much of it can come off as dreary.
Posted by: dr. who at February 26, 2010 2:43 PM
Let me 3rd the painted wood comment. The original wood paneling in most old homes here is paint grade. You CAN'T stain it a natural color because the types and grain of wood used in one room can vary. I don't know about this place in particular, but let's not leap to, "They painted over all the mahogany! Bastards!" Although I've definitely seen it happen...
Posted by: sleepiguy at February 26, 2010 5:05 PM
I like it, tho the street looks a bit busy for my taste and $2M+.
Posted by: Troy at February 27, 2010 9:34 PM
After stripping all the woodwork in my Haight-Ashbury home, a little bit after work each day, night after night for several years I feel that I have earned the right to paint the woodwork in my next home.
Years ago I was on the periphery of the restoration of the "Shelton-McMurphy" house on Skinner's Butte in Eugene, Oregon. We had to duplicate some of the original interior woodwork and were amazed to find that it was white oak that had been faux painted to resemble knotty pine!
Posted by: redseca2 at March 1, 2010 9:39 AM
After languishing on the market for six months with the previous agent and staging...
This go around with Marilyn (Hayes)and Arthur (McLaughlin)got it sold in just THREE days with multiple offers.
Posted by: dzinersf at March 4, 2010 7:37 AM
I'm sure you all did a great job but don't overlook the fact that the 2 to 3M SFR market has gotten a whole lot better than last fall.
Posted by: anonn at March 4, 2010 8:46 AM
I mean, besides this house there are many more examples. But again, a Lower Haight house for 2.5M, on Carmelita? A viewless, attached Mission house for 3.1M at 41 Cumberland? Do those sales occur last fall? Doubtful. A quarter of positive news from a lot of local businesses, plus a year of stock market gains will work wonders on a spring market for monied buyers whose great jobs no longer appear in jeopardy.
Posted by: anonn at March 4, 2010 8:52 AM
Old hardwood is dark and looks withered and old. Love to paint that gloom away!
So many hone "preserve" the old wood at the cost of the selling price.
Paint the cheapest fix available.
Ask any ole ho.
Posted by: kathleen at March 8, 2010 7:03 PM
The sale of 900 Clayton closed escrow 3/32/10 with a reported contract price of $2,275,000 ($812 per square foot).
Don't forget those invitations to the housewarming.
Posted by: SocketSite at April 2, 2010 7:37 AM